Originally published at Better Living Through Science Fiction. Please leave any comments there.
So I was at the comic store picking up my latest round of “Countdown” and “World War Hulk” tie-ins, and I got to thinking about the good old days. Remember when major events used to happen in comics, but they told the stories in the regular monthly ongoing books instead of launching four different mini-series and one-shots on top of the tie-ins? I do, in fact they’re the reason I got into comics in the first place. With that in mind, I decided to come up with a list of my personal favorite crossovers that managed to get told without sucking an extra ten bucks a week out of my allowance.
5. “Avengers Disassembled” - This was a great story that had an impact not only on the publishing of the Avengers, but on the rest of the Marvel Universe, and you really only needed to buy “Avengers” to keep up with it. There were related stories in “Spider-Man” and some of the Avengers’ solo books, but you didn’t have to pick them up to get the gist of things. “Disassembled” also set up the next two summers’ worth of crossovers: “House of M” and “Civil War,” both of which took longer and cost a lot more money to keep up with. This is probably the most recent example of the contained crossover with the exception o
f the current Green Lantern “Sinestro Corps War,” but I ignored it for the moment since that particular story has yet to end.
4. “Maximum Carnage” - Back when Spider-Man had four monthly titles, Marvel decided to add a quarterly one as well, because they knew we would buy it. They secured their investment by putting the first and last parts of “Maximum Carnage” in “Spider-Man Unlimited” numbers 1 and 2, respectively. Marvel never had to put a gun to our heads to get us to buy a Venom or Carnage appearance, but for that summer, New York City ran red while Carnage and his evil gang terrorized the city with Spider-Man, Venom, Black Cat, Captain America and a ton of guest stars in close pursuit, and you were one sad kid if you couldn’t pick up every single issue to see how close Spidey would come to finally putting Cletus Kasady out of business.
3. “Batman: Knightfall” - Superman had just died, so DC was out of juice. They couldn’t do anything else to surprise us, until Bane, a villain who scared a whole generation away from steroids, broke the Bat. We all wondered who could stop him after Bats got taken out of the picture, when all of a sudden a minor anti-hero called “Azrael” took up the mantle, redesigned the Batman costume and cut Bane’s cord. Not only did Jean Paul Valley make the Batman family as unstable as the Manson family, but this crossover set the stage for a golden age of great summer Batman crossovers.
2. “X-Men: X-Tinction Agenda” - Not my personal favorite X-Men crossover, but it set the stage for bigger things to come. The coolest thing about X-Tinction Agenda is that after years of the X-Teams being a loosely-related scattering of mutants around the world, we finally see them come back together. This X-over saw the return of X-Factor’s lineup of original X-Men returning to Xavier’s, the last great mission of the New Mutants, who would go on to become X-Force, and the tying-up of loose ends like Storm being turned into a child and Havok losing his memory. “Agenda” set the tone of the X-Men that catapulted to stardom in the 90’s with the Gold and Blue teams and the ever-expanding X-Family.
1. “The Death of Superman” - I have a special attachment to this storyline because it’s the reason I started collecting comics. It was a big thing even in the comics world, though, regardless of what people say now. Superman got killed, and there wasn’t a miracle cure at the zero hour or some weird time-warp solution. The Man of Steel was gone. Not only was it one of the biggest events in comics history, but they managed to tell the whole story without a one-shot or a mini-series. You just had to pick up a couple of extra issues of the Justice League. Sure, the whole thing is responsible for inflating the cost of comics and putting the second market under a financial strain that would ultimately burst, but when you think about how DC upped the ante and showed us that even their flagship character could be killed, I think we saw the beginning of a grand tradition.